The End of FA Cup Replays

April 23, 2024

Bantams Supporters’ Trust, along with many other Trusts, supporters and EFL and non-league clubs are bitterly disappointed with the FA’s recent announcement that FA Cup replays will be scrapped from the first round onwards.

As well as replays there is real concern across football that many of the things which make the FA Cup special – its history, heritage and tradition – are also under threat.

 

The fourth and fifth rounds and the quarter-finals all will be exclusive of Premier League fixtures for the first time, and the fourth round will have an extended window from Friday to Wednesday to allow fans to watch consecutive days of Emirates FA Cup football.


Taken from the FA’s Statement

 

Stretching a “weekend” from Friday to Monday causes travelling problems to supporters but the FA have agreed to extend that to Wednesdays for the fourth round! Yet even more TV disruption for match-goers.

 

The abandonment of replays means that planning train travel for matches now has to take into account possible extra-time and penalties.

 

Support from the FSA

The FSA (who we are affiliated to) supports replays in the competition. In its’ submission to the Fan-led Review (July 2021, see p84) they argued that the remit of an independent regulator should extend to the FA Cup in order to offer another layer of protection and supporter engagement. This was not included in the Football Governance Bill which is currently passing through Parliament.

 

UEFA to blame?

No football competition organiser exists in isolation. The FA rightly should be held to account and facing protests, but UEFA and the Premier League’s richest clubs are equally complicit. It is their greed that is the basis for this decision.

 

“The start of this process can be traced back to UEFA’s capitulation to the demands of the richest Champions League clubs for whom nothing was ever enough. The competition format never satisfied them as they wanted more and more games (translation – more and more money).

 

This ultimately led to the expansion in European competition which we will see next season with an extra 4-6 Champions League games per club “thanks” to the Swiss Model – and it’s the FA Cup which has paid the price to free up those additional dates.”

Taken from the FSA article on the replays.

 

The last national FSA survey

Their National Supporters Survey (released August 2023) asked a range of questions relating to the FA Cup – they showed that support for replays still exists.


69.5% of fans said replays were an important aspect of the FA Cup.

26.1% were in favour of abolishing replays in the FA Cup.


Meanwhile 38.8% of respondents felt that if both clubs agree in advance then they should be allowed to avoid a replay and go straight to extra time and penalties.


Those stats are based on the responses of almost 10,000 individual supporters.


See more here.


Premier League talks with EFL

From September 2023 the PL have been in discussions with the EPL in view of a draft proposal to them on the structure of potential financial arrangements for them. In those proposals were conditions linked to future funding including cost controls, distribution mechanics, the football calendar and the impact of the Government’s proposed Independent Football Regulator (IFR) as part of the Football Governance White Paper. These proposals were put to the EFL in the knowledge that the PL would be tying up their TV deal arrangements by December.

 

They included proposals wishing to abolish FA Cup replays and have single leg EFL Cup semi-finals but, at the same time, wanted the 16 PL clubs invited to enter the EFL Trophy to play more games! See our article The Premier League TV Deal & It’s proposals to the EFL we put out in December.

 

What we think

Bantams Supporters Trust believe that the broadcasting companies must also be held accountable signing up to these deals to take advantage of selling / televising a ‘product’ to millions of supporters, making vast amounts of profits in the process.

 

The broadcasting companies are inexorably linked to all the major football competitions as they provide the competitions so much wealth where the richest clubs are rewarded the most.

 

As part of the FA and PL’s proposal to do away with replays was to compensate smaller clubs by investing more in grassroots football, but that should be a given anyway and there is no sign of an agreement from the PL to redistribute it’s wealth as part of a commitment to sustain the game, and it is a requirement of the Football Governance Bill.

 

The magic of the FA Cup is real, but only just, and like a star it fades, and it is fading every year through decisions made by the few, to the detriment of our beloved game. It shouldn’t be this way.

 

Supporters being organized and active as a collective voice is the key to begin to turn that around.


November 14, 2026
The Trust has brought out a new line of badges, introducing the first of its kind at the start of this season, 2026/27. We also have a black and silver one signifying the tragedy of 1985 with the words, ‘Always Remember’ on the banner. We ordered 200 of each priced at £4 per badge and have sold very well on our stalls. You can also find them on eBay UK here . There is a further cost of £3.50 for first class post. You can also order them by request by email at hello@bantamstrust.co.uk , and you can send us payment by use of bank transfer, see details here . We are totally out of our original enamel badge design, but that’s not to say we can’t reproduce it in the future. 
November 12, 2026
A website dedicated to Bradford City badges has just been relaunched. www.bradfordcitybadges.co.uk . The website catalogues and features the badge collection of long time City supporter, Jeremy White. Jeremy states “There are over 2,600 different Bradford City badges featured on the website, displayed in 30 different categories. I would be grateful if Trust members would check out the website and give me their feedback. I am always in the lookout for old Bradford City badges, so if you have any to sell, please get in touch with me via the website.” Jeremy has in the past, donated more than £20,000 from Bantams badge sales to Bradford City AFC. In addition he has also helped to raise in excess of £25,000 for the Bradford Burns Unit (PSBRU) from the sale of commemorative badges and the Bantams flat cap initiative.
November 5, 2026
On 29 October, representatives of the Supporters Trust met with representatives of Tiffin Stadium Catering Richard Cullen, Managing Director, and James Tinsley, Director of Operations, at City Vaults to discuss supporters’ feedback on catering at Valley Parade. The meeting provided an opportunity to discuss the current offering, explain the practical considerations behind matchday service and hear suggestions for future improvements. Tiffin is responsible for the stadium kiosks this season, with hospitality catering provided separately. Richard and James explained that delivering matchday catering involves balancing product choice, quality and speed of service, particularly during the short, busy periods before kick-off and at half-time. As with many established football grounds, the available space and facilities vary between kiosks. These influence the equipment that can be accommodated and the products that can be prepared and served efficiently and safely. Some suggestions, including a wider range of freshly cooked dishes, would require additional equipment or supporting facilities/rooms before they could be introduced safely at the volumes required. The range therefore varies between kiosks according to facilities and demand. Staffing is also directed towards the busiest service points to help manage queues and serve supporters efficiently. The discussion covered developments this season, including the introduction of self-service beer stations and the recent trial of the “ultimate hotdog” at the local derby. Tiffin remains keen to explore further additions where they can be delivered consistently within the matchday operation. Supporters’ feedback on pie serving temperatures was also discussed, highlighting the importance of a consistent experience. Specific feedback identifying the kiosk, fixture and product would help Tiffin investigate individual concerns. Pricing was another subject raised. Richard and James explained that prices reflect food and drink purchasing costs, wages and employer National Insurance, packaging, delivery and the preparation and staffing required for matchday service. Tiffin recognises that value matters to supporters and aims to balance affordability with product quality and reliable service. The Trust thanked Richard and James for an open and constructive discussion. Both welcomed continued feedback and expressed their willingness to meet supporters again, with a shared interest in improving the matchday experience at Valley Parade.
November 4, 2026
The Supporters Trust would like to take the opportunity to express our deepest condolences to the family and friends of Geoffrey Richmond, our late chairman. His enigmatic personality and his input into Bradford city culminating in the two seasons in the Premier League were filled with some wonderful memories for the supporters. He played his part in the Bradford City story and will not be forgotten.
November 3, 2026
Our AGM is on Wednesday, 24th November, from 7pm, at Jacobs Well , near Bradford Interchange. This is your opportunity to make your voice be heard and contribute to making us stronger in terms of building the Trust membership and our finances, but we also want to influence the Club in securing it’s long term success and longevity, bringing in supporter-led initiatives along the way that improve the match day experience for all. You will get to hear about our achievements through our reports at the AGM. The existing Trust Board would like to see new Trust Board Members that have new ideas and proposals that will broaden our reach. Find out how you can play a role in the Trust here . If you would like to be a Board Member, please find a Board Member Nomination form for this year here . All Board Members are volunteers and we are a not for profit organisation. The deadline for submitting your nominations is Wednesday 18 th November 2025. There is space for a candidate’s statement on the form, and a proposer and seconder need to be members. For any enquiries about being a Board Member please contact us here . Members who receive our regular emails will be able to download our Draft Agenda and Papers for the evening nearer the time. For our AGM to be quorate, we need 20 Members in attendance. Only Members can vote. The AGM will start at 7pm, so please arrive in good time to order a drink at the bar. We will be in the snug area of the pub and greet members at the bar from 6.30pm. We understand that many of you will live across the country and further beyond, and therefore to encourage attendance we will have a hybrid meeting as in previous years, of members, in person, in the pub, or online video via Zoom. The Zoom meeting link will be provided nearer the time. We look forward to seeing you in due course.
October 22, 2026
Tiffin want to engage with supporters about the choice or lack of food and drink on the concourse Kiosk bars at Bradford City and have called a meeting for Thursday 29 th October at City Vaults for 6pm. Here is your opportunity to offer suggestions in person. To get an indication of interest in attending, please contact Helen Jeffery by emailing hello@bantamstrust.co.uk . You do not have to be a member of the Trust to attend. Anyone not able to attend but wanting to put forward any ideas, please Email us at hello@bantamstrust.co.uk . We can then collate any information to take to the meeting. We thank you for your support
October 8, 2026
On the 6 th October Bradford City announced Michael Duff as the new First Team Manager. Duff, 48, in his playing career as a defender and a former Northern Ireland International, became a firm favourite amongst supporters at Cheltenham Town, helping them get promoted twice, once during the 1997 season, and then in 1999 when he scored the goal that got them promoted into the Football League. He later contributed to the club’s promotion to the third tier through the play-offs in 2002. In 2004, he joined Burnley from Cheltenham for a reported £30,000, and in 2009 helped them win promotion to the Premier League through the play-offs, and since helped them win promotion back into the Premier League two other times, in 2014 and 2016 respectively. In Duff’s managerial career (2017-18) he worked within Burnley’s coaching structure. In 2018 he came back to Cheltenham, and in 2021 Led Cheltenham to the League Two title. In 2022 he joined Barnsley and in the following year he took them to the League One Play-Off Final. In that year, 2023, he had a spell as Head Coach of Swansea City and in 2024 joined Huddersfield Town. In 2025 he then managed Wycombe Wanderers. So far in his managerial career, Duff has taken charge of 376 games, winning 160 and drawing 96. Whilst he has had managerial successes he has faced difficulties at Clubs facing different expectations. Michael Duff’s Management Style is one where his approach is based strongly on unity, work ethic, adaptability, and collective responsibility. His teams have been associated with organised pressing and an ability to build play from the back. He has also shown a willingness to adjust his tactical approach according to the strengths of his players. Another important part of his philosophy is creating a strong connection between players, staff, and supporters. These qualities are very much in the mould of two of our best managers in the modern era, Phil Parkinson and Graham Alexander and therefore it is understandable the Club’s senior figures see that he can fit into their Club vision. We are aware that there will be a lot of expectation from within the Club and amongst supporters as there is a strong ambition of competing higher in the English football structure. We believe that a manager has to have the time and the resources to develop and bring about successes. The conditions are ripe for Duff to succeed with all the ambition and expectation to reach the Championship. It is a tough pressure, but one that Michael Duff will be relishing. The Trust gives Duff our backing and we hope that all supporters will give him time to get the players’ backing. We are only too aware that the pressure for success has created culture of a managerial merry-go-round where careers of managers at clubs are often cut short. We can only hope that Michael Duff’s success at Bradford City is the exception to this. The season’s campaign is still long and we are sure there will still be highs and lows. We are also confident that if the spirit is strong and determined throughout the team we are sure supporters will get behind him.
October 8, 2026
Bantams Supporters Trust have been approached by the Club’s stadium concourse catering company Tiffin to try to arrange an open meeting in the next couple of months to discuss the foods and beverages provided in the concourse outlets. This would give both parties the chance to discuss what it is that supporters would like to see provided at games and Tiffin the chance to discuss what can and cannot be provided in the stadium. The City Vaults has been suggested as a venue and probably a mid week evening would be the best time for all involved. To get an indication of interest in attending, please contact Helen Jeffery by emailing hello@bantamstrust.co.uk . You do not have to be a member of the Trust to attend. Anyone not able to attend but wanting to put forward any ideas, please Email us at hello@bantamstrust.co.uk . We can then collate any information to take to the meeting. We thank you for your support
September 29, 2026
After much speculation surrounding the possibility that he was to leave for Preston North End, and then confirmation that the Club had reluctantly let him talk to the Club on the 24 th September, we reflect with sadness that it has finally been confirmed on Monday 28 th that Graham Alexander has now left the Club. He had been with us for almost 3 years from November 2023 when he picked up the struggling team, that by the end of that campaign, narrowly missed promotion by just one point of reaching the Play-Offs. The following season, his first full season brought us automatic promotion in one of the most dramatic end of last matches of the season at Valley Parade in the Club’s history. There were scenes of unbridled joy that afternoon that seemed like all the difficult years of lack of success and ambition had evaporated into the air. During that season the team managed to win 10 consecutive home wins. In our new League one season Graham Alexander led his team into the playoffs but was unsuccessful in reaching the dizzy heights of the Championship. Graham Alexander in his time as manager brought in a raft of new players and was able bring the team together. He brought a confidence to the team and with it a team that could fight for points and beat teams, and the success on the pitch brought fans back and won many new ones. Fans could sing with pride. But we must not dwell on what we have lost. A manager’s career is very short these days at any one club, and we must look ahead and wish success to Graham Alexander, one of the revered amongst the Club’s support base and his assistant manager, Chris Lucketti at Preston North End. In the interim period while we wait for a new manager we must give our support to Mark Trueman and Colin Doyle. With all the success we have had in the time Graham Alexander has been with us, he leaves us in a stronger position as a club financially and a much more exciting prospect as a club to come to as a manager. With a big support base, all the ingredients are there for much more successes at Bradford City. We are only at the beginning of October, so we are sure to have a few bumps on the journey.
September 28, 2026
The Supporters Trust would like to bring up some issues that have been brought to our attention by disabled supporters and elderly supporters attending away games and how upsetting they can be. My name is Helen Jeffery, a disabled supporter, and an avid City fan who has recently joined the Supporters Trust Board. At away grounds disabled supporters are often allocated places directly behind the goal or to the left or right at the front of an away enclosure. As a result, and in particularly when we bring a big following, we often find that that intoxicated supporters are coming down the steps, standing in front of us blocking our line of site, pushing and jostling wheelchairs and even falling on our supporters. It can be frightening and even when the stewards step in to quell the situation, some of those supporters argue and refuse to move. This is particularly evident when celebrating goals. It can put vulnerable supporters at risk to injury. The Trust is appealing to anyone who knows any of these supporters to just remind them that not all disabilities are visible and to be more mindful of other supporters around them. I love the team as much as the next supporter but games are becoming harder to go to when you are frightened of your own fan-base. We have raised these issues several times with the Club and the West Yorkshire Police Dedicated Football Officer, see our last report of when we raised safety issues, and I have contacted other clubs, and lessons are being learnt by clubs but we still need your support to help us make the game safer so that we can all go, be safe and enjoy the beautiful game we all love. Thank you in advance for supporting this appeal and if anyone has any feedback/ideas and your own experiences for me please email the Trust at hello@bantamstrust.co.uk and I will contact you directly. We have also asked our Club to put out a message on matchdays appealing for fans to be mindful and considerate, as it may have more impact. Forever Bantams Helen Jeffery Women’s and Disability Officer